Affiliate Disclosure: Sanctuary Mattress earns a commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you. We only recommend mattresses that meet our premium quality standards.
Most people spend less than five minutes testing a mattress in a showroom before making a decision they’ll live with for a decade. That’s not enough time — and most people don’t know what to evaluate when they’re lying on a mattress in a store. Here’s how to do it properly.
Dress for Testing
Wear or bring comfortable clothes you can lie on a mattress in — not work clothes or jeans that restrict your movement. Testing a mattress in street clothes gives you an incomplete picture. Bring your own pillow if you have a specific loft preference — the showroom pillows may skew your assessment.
Spend Real Time on Each Position
Spend at least 10–15 minutes on each mattress you’re seriously considering. Lie in your actual primary sleep position — side, back, or stomach — not just on your back with your arms at your sides. Your body takes 5–7 minutes to fully relax and register how the mattress feels at pressure points.
Evaluate Pressure Points
For side sleepers: pay attention to the shoulder and hip. Do they feel comfortable, or do you feel the mattress pushing back against them? For back sleepers: is there a gap at the lower back, or does the mattress support the lumbar curve? For stomach sleepers: does your lower back curve upward (too soft) or is it supported without strain?
Test Edge Support
Sit on the edge of the mattress at about one-third of the way in. Does it hold your weight without excessive collapse? This matters for getting in and out of bed and for couples who use the full mattress width. A strong perimeter coil system maintains its height under sitting weight.
Test Motion Transfer with a Partner
If you share a bed, bring your partner. Have one person lie still while the other shifts position. How much movement transfers? For light sleepers who share a bed, this is one of the most important in-store tests.
Ask the Right Questions
Ask about: the return/trial policy and what it covers, the warranty terms (full vs. limited, what voids it), delivery timeline and setup options, and whether the mattress you’re testing is the same firmness as what you’d receive delivered. Some showroom models are broken-in from years of testing.